County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust will expand a review of breast cancer cases to include up to 4,500 patients dating back to 2015, after identifying failings including delayed diagnoses and unnecessary surgeries. The review, which began in April 2025 examining cases from 2023-2025, has already assessed 538 cases, finding harm in 321, including one death. Board chair Alison Marshall offered a “sincere apology” to affected women and families at an extraordinary meeting, acknowledging the “impact” of the failings. Concerns were initially raised in 2015 following a service reconfiguration and a reduction in breast surgical trainee posts, with multiple issues subsequently raised by patients, the Northern Cancer Alliance, the Care Quality Commission, and NHS England. Key themes identified included treatment not aligned with best practice, excessive surgery, and delayed diagnosis. The initial year of the review cost approximately £523,000 and involved nine reviewers examining around 80 cases per month. The expanded review is expected to take five years to complete and will adopt a “proportionate and evidence-led clinical approach,” according to chief nurse Gill Hunt. Hunt also stated the trust is committed to learning from the failures in responding to concerns raised by patients and agencies. Approximately 640 patients have contacted a special helpline requesting their cases be reviewed.
Our reading is that this expanded review represents a significant admission of past failings by the County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust. The scale of the review, covering nearly 4,500 cases dating back to 2015, suggests systemic issues beyond isolated incidents. The Trust’s apology and commitment to learning from failures, coupled with the initial findings of harm in a majority of assessed cases, indicate a serious breach of patient safety standards.
Read the original coverage
💬 Comments
📜 Comment Policy